Thoughts on a Humanities Knowledge System
I am a humanities‑trained scholar specializing in medical humanities and STS, so I often read about how scientists collaborate and organize their knowledge. It’s fascinating, and sometimes I find myself envying them, wondering whether the humanities should also cultivate a knowledge‑production system like scientists do. Of course, I understand there are fundamental differences between how knowledge is produced in the humanities and in the hard sciences. But as an STS scholar, I also recognize that knowledge in the sciences is not simply “born that way”; it undergoes disciplinary shaping. Naturally, there are critiques of this mode of generating knowledge—seeing it as a linear accumulation—but we cannot deny the immense accomplishments of science, can we? So what I’m thinking is: why don’t the humanities organize our knowledge in a similar way, or at least take inspiration from the sciences? Imagine a database of knowledge, with scholars contributing to build it, and anyone who wants to...